The Top 5 Things to Order at Nick & Toni’s


CHICKEN 11.16.13

The chicken!

You’ve heard of Nick & Toni’s, because everyone’s heard of Nick & Toni’s. It’s the East End’s best restaurant, a powerhouse during the summer and exceptional twelve months a year. There’s a garden on property and sourcing is as local as possible. Conde Nast Traveler calls a meal there, “a farm-and-ocean-to-table Italian feast.”

So, here’s what to order:

1. La Quercia Plate: An American made artisanal cured meats spread including prosciutto picante, lomo and nduja with grilled Tuscan toast and house made pickled vegetables. The best things in life come in 3s.

2. Balsam Farms Zucchini Chips: No, you don’t need them. But you want them.

3. Free Range Chicken: A Nick & Toni’s classic. This free range chicken is oven roasted and served over crispy Yukon gold potatoes with roasted garlic, pancetta & rosemary jus.

4. Wood Roasted Striped Bass: TG for fishermen. This local fish is wood oven roasted over Balsam Farms Swiss chard, fingerling potatoes and is then topped with a tomato beurre blanc.

5. Tartufo: Behold, the best dessert in the Hamptons.

Bonus. A Pepino Sour. If you’re looking for a refreshing beverage with a spicy kick, here it is. Made with Cimarron tequila, cucumber, fresh lime and a dash of Cholula, this libation served over ice with a salted chili rim.

Make a reservation at Nick & Toni’s.

Discover More


The Resy Guide to Chicago’s Essential Cozy Locales

The Road Back

“You Can Just Feel The Energy.” Bloodwood and Claire Van Vuuren Are Making Up For Lost Time


Dish By Dish

How Chef Zarah Khan Brought New Energy to Botanica, As Seen in Five Dishes


Nine Exceptional Private Dining Options in Charleston


Ten Wonderful Christmas Menus for Celebrating in London

Chef Features

Wylie Dufresne Finds His Ultimate Challenge (Spoiler: It’s Pizza)

Resy Lineup

The Resy Lineup: Last-Minute Pies, How to Get Into Saint Theo’s, and a Certain Raclette Window Returns


Ten of London’s Best Private Dining Rooms For a Special Celebration


The Rundown

Everything You Need to Know About Cobi’s, Now Open in Santa Monica


10 Boston Private Dining Rooms Perfect For a Special Celebration


Twelve Excellent Private Dining Rooms in New York

Chef Features

Seven Incredible Holiday Dishes, According to New York Chefs — and Where You Can Find Them


Nine Wonderful Private Dining Options in San Francisco and Oakland