Photo courtesy of Josephine

The Hit ListBoston

The Resy Hit List: Where In Boston You’ll Want to Eat in May 2025

By

There’s no question we hear more often: Where should I go eat? And while we at Resy know it’s an honor to be the friend who everyone asks for restaurant advice, we also know it’s a complicated task. That’s where the Resy Hit List comes in. 

Consider it your essential resource for dining in Boston: a monthly-updated guide to the restaurants that you won’t want to miss — tonight or any night.

Four Things In Boston Not to Miss This Month

  • Book It: On Saturday, May 3rd, the Kendall Square location of Mamaleh’s Delicatessen is hosting a meet-and-greet with author Beejhy Barhany, whose new book “Gursha!” celebrates Ethiopian-Jewish cuisine. Tickets here
  • Wine and Dine: Sonoma comes to Talulla on Tuesday, May 20th, in the form of a four-course dinner paired with wines from Jolie-Laide vineyard; tickets here. And if you’re just looking to drop in somewhere for a good glass of wine, a reservation at Gray’s Hall, haley.henry Wine Bar, or Spoke Wine Bar will surely scratch the itch.
  • Brunch so Hard: Mother’s Day, graduation season, the general return to outdoor dining — it’s prime brunching season in Boston, and our brunch guide remains an essential resource. And per Mother’s Day in particular, the deck is stacked with brunch at La Morra, a four-course prix fixe at Amar, a Contessa prix fixe with bakery baskets and veal Milanese, a very French meal courtesy of Deuxave, a Matria buffet stacked with sushi and prime tenderloin, and a La Padrona three-courser with caviar and truffle supplements galore.
  • So Much Soul: Roxbury has a brand-new purveyor of comfort food in the form of Soul on Shawmut, which is now up and running with smoked mac ‘n’ cheese, collard greens, and fried wings to spare; walk-ins only.

New to the Hit List (May 2025)
Da LaPosta, Josephine, Noah’s Kitchen, The Sea Hag Restaurant and Bar.

1. Noah's Kitchen Brookline

map

Photo courtesy of Noah’s Kitchen

Mala: a Chinese word roughly translating to “numbing and spicy” — a sensation you’ll be well familiar with about 20 minutes after sitting down to a meal at Noah’s Kitchen, Brookline’s latest purveyor of Sichuan cooking. The eponymous peppercorn comes fast and furious here, via dishes like twice-cooked pork belly, grilled whole fish, and even a sautéed spicy bullfrog casserole. Also of note: mapo tofu, hot pot beef brisket, and housemade dumplings as far as the eye can see. 

Book Now

Photo courtesy of Noah’s Kitchen

2. Zurito Beacon Hill

map

Nevermind that Jamie Bissonnette already had a threepeat, with Somaek, Temple Records, and Sushi @ Temple Records earlier this year. Turns out Bissonnette and his partners at BCB3 Hospitality had one more up their sleeve, in the Charles Street space that was Bin Enoteca 26. Basque-style pintxos are the mission here, with bites of garlic-buttered sea urchin toast or miniature jamón Ibérico croissants giving way to such small plates as squid ink risotto. All of which sets the stage for large-format finishers, including a 32-ounce ribeye with French fries and kimchi (why not?).  An expectedly Spanish-heavy wine list is rounded out by a roster of low-ABV cocktails that complement the restaurant’s snacky ethos.

Book Now

3. Baleia South End

map

For years, the Coda Restaurant Group has played in the Italian sandbox, whether with wood-fired pies and housemade pastas at The Salty Pig, Venetian-style small plates via SRV, and most recently, the restaurant-cum-café Gufo. But the group’s latest venture eschews the boot in favor of flavors from another peninsular nation: Portugal. Baleia bets big on Portuguese seafood with oysters spiced by piri piri, steamed baby clams in Vinho Verde, and an entire roasted fish with ham and anchovy XO. Landlubbers can be contented by a lamb shank served with spicy pickles or a sucking pig complete with crispy ears. Its quick popularity affirms that the shift in peninsulas was a smart bet.

Book Now

4. Folio Downtown

map

Folio — the open-to-the-public cafe that quite literally bookends the Boston Athenaeum, an esteemed members’ library — has refreshed itself for spring. And it’s a refreshment worth paying proper attention to, as it includes pressed maitake consommé, duck rillette gougère (read: very fancy sliders) with blue cheese and kumquat agrodolce, and mushroom and Madeira chicken pies. Meanwhile, the cocktail menu refreshes in another way, with specialties like Alice’s Wonderland with milk-washed gin, hibiscus, caramelized banana, pineapple, and guava.

Book Now

5. Sarma Winter Hill

map

Photo by Susan Kuscher, courtesy of Sarma

There’s something to be said — nay, a lot to be said — about the sort of restaurant in an otherwise sleepy neighborhood that still books up weeks in advance, more than 10 years after opening. Sarma is that. Yes, the bevy of awards has helped, but that would shortchange the constant creativity of chef Cassie Piuma, whose Turkish meyhane concept still resonates a decade in. Piuma has maintained her Somerville spot as a laboratory for Mediterranean flavors, pumping out playful mezze like lentil nachos, brussels sprouts bravas, and harissa barbecue duck, while still keeping diners on their toes for whenever the Turkish fried chicken — which can only be ordered direct from the tray — comes out of the kitchen.

Book Now

Photo by Susan Kuscher, courtesy of Sarma

6. Matria Downtown

map

Piedmontese cuisine — hailing from the Northwestern region of Italy that sits just below the Alps — is the order of the day at Matria, an Italian steakhouse nestled within the Intercontinental Boston. What’s not on the menu is red sauce (an eggplant Parmigiana drizzled with San Marzanos is about as close as it gets). What is: Beef tartare with capers and shaved truffles, housemade pastas including a veal and beef short rib agnolotti with English peas, and a whole “bistecca” portion of the menu that tops off with a 44-ounce tomahawk for two. Yes, you’re going to need a bag.

Book Now

7. Josephine Somerville

map

Italian the old-school way is the organizing principle behind Josephine in Somerville’s Cambria Hotel. It comes to us from chef Michael Scelfo (of Alden & Harlow, Waypoint, and Longfellow Bar fame), whose homage to traditional Italian American cooking goes something like this: dry-aged meatballs, skillet eggplant parmesan, rigatoni with vodka sauce and housemade sausage, deep dish pies with spicy ‘roni cups — you get the picture.

Book Now

8. Birds of Paradise Brighton

map

International travel — via bar stool — is the theme at Birds of Paradise, which comes from the acclaimed team behind Baldwin Bar and Blossom Bar. Each drink is presented as a one-way ticket from one far-flung destination to another, with the resulting concoction incorporating elements of both locales. For instance, the Rio to Tokyo contains both cachaça and a wasabi-coconut cordial, or the Dublin to Caracas with Irish whisky, banana, and tonka bean. The globe-hopping theme similarly extends to the food menu, packed with snacks like pork gyoza and poke bowls.

Book Now

9. The Sea Hag Restaurant and Bar Harvard Square

map

Grendel’s Den — the subterranean watering hole that’s been beloved by Harvard undergrads and grads alike since 1871 — has gained a little sister in the form of The Sea Hag. The airy establishment makes its bones on oysters and modern, seafood-forward interpretations of traditional pub fare, including skillet-braised Mediterranean haddock, tempura fish tacos, and Mozambique-style shrimp in a garlicky saffron sauce. It also boasts what might be the Square’s most enticing special: a pint of Guinness and an oyster for just shy of $10.

Book Now

10. Oleana Cambridge

map

Photo courtesy of Oleana

Yes, Sarma remains one of the most coveted reservations in the city. But that shouldn’t overshadow its older sibling restaurant, which Ana Sortun first opened in 2001. The culinary focus is similarly centered on Turkey but in more traditional form, with dishes like squash-stuffed manouri dumplings, Vermont quail kebabs, and a za’atar-spiced lemon chicken with cheese pancakes taking center stage. And though not quite Turkish in origin, the house iteration of Baked Alaska has deservedly entered the Boston dessert canon.

Book Now

Photo courtesy of Oleana

11. Woods Hill Pier 4 – Seaport Seaport

map

By virtue of its attachment to the same-named New Hampshire farm, Woods Hill Pier 4’s menu is organized around seasonality and a nose-to-tail ethos. What that’s meant in plated form lately is dishes including sunflower risotto with pickled sweet potato, smoked pork and foie gras bratwurst with spaetzle, and a formidable range of housemade pastas like cresto di gallo with red wine-braised duck. Throw in panoramic Boston Harbor views from their glass-walled dining room, and you’re truly getting the best of land and sea.

Book Now

12. Bar Enza Harvard

map

Lydia Shire — who you might recall as the first female winner of a James Beard Award, the chef and co-owner of Scampo, or a myriad of other highlights from her 50-year career — has just added another notch to her belt as culinary director of Bar Enza at the Charles Hotel in Harvard Square. With a menu already stacked with the likes of lamb merguez gnocchi and 14-ounce bisteccas with potato croquettes, it’s an auspicious start for the Italian restaurant group’s latest act.

Book Now

13. Qué Mas Beverly

map

Qué Mas — roughly translated as “what else?” — is a fitting moniker for this modern pan-Latin spot in Beverly, which serves as a culinary tour of Central and South America. Stops include sweet corn arepas with burrata and sundried tomato pesto, swordfish al pastor with grits and pineapple salsa, and braised lamb ossobuco served in grilled banana leaves. Fun fact: chef Alex Pineda is the son of legendary Boston-area chef Lydia Shire, and came up working at Scampo.

Book Now

14. Contessa Boston Back Bay

map

In Boston, Contessa has quite nearly cornered the market on seeing-and-being-seen. But as glamorous as this rooftop jewel box of a restaurant — and many of its patrons — might be, you’re coming here for more than views, since Major Food Group (of New York’s Carbone) doesn’t miss a beat on memorable dishes. Specifically, spicy lobster capellini, eye-popping 40-ounce bisteccas, and some of the best made Negronis on this side of the Atlantic.

Book Now

15. Da LaPosta Newtonville

map

Newtonville may be a long way from Naples, but chef Mario LaPosta is helping to bridge that gap with his eponymous restaurant specializing in naturally leavened, wood-fired pies and high-end takes on Southern Italian street food. Imagine: delicately fried calamari and housemade ricotta accompanied by hot honey, followed by pizza crowned with fresh figs and lardo or grilled ramps, ‘nduja, and mozzarella. Add in an enviable selection of wines sourced from the Boot’s lower half, and you’ve got yourself a stamp-free passport to Italy.

Book Now

16. LoLa 42 Seaport

map

No ferry is required to visit LoLa 42, the Seaport outpost of the beloved Nantucket institution Lola 41 Nantucket. Like its equivalent, the menu has a hyper-specific focus on cuisines that fall along the 42nd parallel. Fortunately, that makes for fare like beef bulgogi bao, spicy scallop sushi rolls, and cavatelli Bolognese. Always of interest is the Lola Burger, made with red onion compote and foie gras sauce and served on an English muffin.

Book Now

17. Boston Chops – South End South End

map

With a new class of neo-steakhouses suddenly sprouting up from Downtown to Charlestown, it’s worth remembering the venue that helped kickstart the trend way back in 2013 — and is still going strong (along with its sister Boston Chops Downtown). With its moody, low-lit interior and classic but never stodgy dishes like roasted bone marrow with balsamic onion jam, lardon-topped iceberg wedge salads, and filet mignon with goat cheese potato croquettes, it’s a fresh reminder that steakhouses are worth seeking out, expense account or not.

Book Now

18. Mimi's Chuka Diner Union Square

map

After soft-opening for take-out last fall, Mimi’s Chuka Diner — to recap, that’s Chinese cuisine as cooked in Japan — is firing on all cylinders (and accepting reservations) at its space inside Aeronaut Brewing Co. Expect crunchy kombu-brined chicken karaage, fried pork gyoza, and extra-garlicky garlic noodles, plus more surprising fare like a wagyu burger with yaki-barbecue sauce and Kewpie mayo.

Book Now

19. Desnuda Cocina & Bar South End

map

Once it was Tremont 647. Then it was the short-lived Whaling in Oklahoma. Then it was … nothing, for a long time. But one of the South End’s most eligible corner spaces has been reborn as Desnuda, a new concept from the folks behind KAVA Neo-Taverna, Ilona, and Gigi. This latest venture is a bi-level affair, split between a swanky upstairs dining room specializing in Asian and Latin cuisine (think: baos and ceviche), and a seriously vibey downstairs listening bar equipped with a custom sound system, vinyl, and cocktails.

Book Now

20. Bar Fellini Downtown

map

Photo courtesy of Bar Fellini

Also ensconced within the Intercontinental Boston, Bar Fellini is a sort of sibling establishment to Matria, specializing in aperitivo cocktails (i.e., you’ll want to drop in here to pique your appetite before sitting down to bistecca at the latter). Around a horseshoe-shaped bar that looks right out of a … Fellini movie, you’ll partake in Aperol spritzes or original creations like the Juliet of Spirits (grappa, bergamot liqueur, fig syrup), and maybe even snack on short rib arancini or burrata toast if you start to feel a bit peckish.

Book Now

Photo courtesy of Bar Fellini